Wednesday, 27 January 2016

Out for the count



At the start of the Winterbourne View/Transforming Care programme to get (some) people with learning disabilities out of specialist inpatient services, it became very clear that information about the number of people in inpatient services, and what was happening to them, was pretty much absent. The National Audit Office (see https://www.nao.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Care-services-for-people-with-learning-disabilities-and-challenging-behaviour.pdf ) and the Public Accounts Committee gave NHS England a good going over about this in 2015.

Although the determined invisibility of people with learning disabilities in inpatient services had been an issue for some years, the Health and Social Care Act (2012) made a bad situation worse in terms of trying to collect comprehensive information. At the end of September 2015, according to data collected from (most) commissioners (HSCIC Assuring Transformation, see http://www.hscic.gov.uk/catalogue/PUB19833 ), people with learning disabilities and/or autism were being kept in inpatient services by 204 out of 209 local Clinical Commissioning Groups, and 10 regional NHS England specialist commissioning hubs. According to the Learning Disability Census (see HSCIC http://www.hscic.gov.uk/article/6874/Learning-Disability-Census-2015-almost-half-of-inpatients-with-learning-disabilities-common-to-each-census-since-2013 ), at the end of September 2015 people with learning disabilities and/or autism were in English inpatient services run by 58 different NHS Trusts and 31 different independent sector organisations.

NHS England and the Health and Social Care Information Centre at the moment have three sources of information about people with learning disabilities and/or autism in inpatient services.

Monthly Assuring Transformation data (see http://www.hscic.gov.uk/catalogue/PUB19833 - I last discussed information from this dataset on this blog here http://chrishatton.blogspot.co.uk/2015/11/impatient-inpatient.html ). This is information collected every month from health service commissioners in England (although not all of them send in returns every month) about how many people with learning disabilities and/or autism they are paying for in inpatient services. Although they are all English commissioners, the numbers should include people who they have sent to inpatient services out of England (Wales and Scotland, most likely) as well as people in inpatient services in England.

The Learning Disability Census (see http://www.hscic.gov.uk/article/6874/Learning-Disability-Census-2015-almost-half-of-inpatients-with-learning-disabilities-common-to-each-census-since-2013 ). This collects information from inpatient service providers in England about which people with learning disabilities and/or autism are in their inpatient services at the end of September each year. This could include people in English inpatient services who have been sent there from commissioners outside England (again, most likely to be Scotland and Wales).

Mental Health and Learning Disabilities Dataset Statistics (see http://www.hscic.gov.uk/catalogue/PUB19578 ). This information is also collected monthly, from a wide range of providers of mental health and learning disability specialist services in England, although so far there have been no reports breaking down in detail the number of people using different types of specialist learning disability service (this includes inpatient services, but also specialist community services).

The Learning Disability Census (which was done in 2013, 2014 and 2015) is not planned to be repeated in 2016. Instead, the other two sources of information (Assuring Transformation and the Mental Health and Learning Disabilities Dataset Statistics - MHLDDS) are supposed to be able to take up the slack and provide all the information needed about people with learning disabilities and/or autism in inpatient services. As things stand at the moment, I think this assumption is debatable.

From what we know, it’s possible that both the Assuring Transformation and MHLDDS datasets are going to miss significant numbers of people that, according to the Learning Disability Census, are in specialist inpatient services.

First, the Health and Social Care Information Centre has done a detailed analysis comparing people with learning disabilities and/or autism reported to be in inpatient services at the end of September 2015, according to Assuring Transformation versus the Learning Disability Census (this analysis is reported in the Learning Disability Census report). In total the Learning Disability Census reported 3,000 people in inpatient services, compared to 2,625 people reported in Assuring Transformation. In total 2,140 people were reported in both datasets to be in an inpatient service at the end of September, 855 people were inpatients according to the Learning Disability Census but not Assuring Transformation, and 480 people were inpatients according to Assuring Transformation but not the Learning Disability Census.

Some of these differences might be explainable. For example, in Assuring Transformation commissioners regularly ‘find’ more people that they report retrospectively, so the number of people in inpatient services at the end of September reported by commissioners will increase. There are also some people picked up by the Learning Disability Census in English places that are not commissioned by English commissioners (and so not included in Assuring Transformation). Conversely, Assuring Transformation should pick up people in places outside England (so not included in the Learning Disability Census) that have been commissioned by English commissioners. Taking all these together, it means that we’re still not clear how many people with learning disabilities and/or autism are in inpatient services at any one time, with the potential numbers of people being anything from around 2,600 people to 3,500 people.

Second, will the MHLDDS pick up information on everyone identified in the Learning Disability Census as being in a specialist inpatient service? To get a rough handle on this, I looked at both the Learning Disability Census and the MHLDDS for the lists of service providers from which data were collected at the end of September 2015 (these are available in the HSCIC online data tables). In total there were 26 provider organisations mentioned in the Learning Disability Census that were not in the MHLDDS list, with at least 445 people with learning disabilities and/or autism living in these places according to the Learning Disability Census.

These organisations included six NHS Trusts with a total of 60 people:
·        3 children’s trusts (Alder Hey 5 people; Sheffield Children’s 5 people; Birmingham Children’s 5 people)
·        2 community trusts (Derbyshire Community Health Services 5 people; Birmingham Community Healthcare 20 people)
·        Puzzlingly, 1 mental health trust (Norfolk & Suffolk 20 people)

They also included eight independent providers with fewer than 5 people each (Shrewsbury Court Independent Hospital; The Lane Project; Alternative Futures Group; Turning Point; Vision Mental Healthcare; Eden Supported Living; Making Space; The Retreat Hospital York).

Finally, they included 12 independent providers with 5 or more people (totalling 385 people between them):
·        Turning Point (Rotherham) 10 people
·        The Breightmet Centre for Autism 5 people
·        Baldock Manor (Nouvita Ltd) 5 people
·        Danshell Group 85 people
·        Equilibrium Healthcare 30 people
·        Curocare Ltd 30 people
·        Glen Care 5 people
·        Lighthouse Healthcare Ltd 85 people
·        St Mathews Healthcare 25 people
·        Jeesal Akman Care Corporation Ltd 40 people
·        Brookdale Healthcare Ltd 40 people
·        Cheswold Park Hospital 25 people

If the Learning Disability Census is not to be repeated, these providers need to be checked (it’s possible that there are some errors in the Learning Disability Census, particularly among providers identified with less than 5 people) and added to the list of providers in the MHLDDS dataset. Apart from this practical step, there are much bigger issues that confront anyone trying to collect meaningful information about people with learning disabilities and/or autism in inpatient services.

First, clarity is needed about whether to collect information about people in inpatient services in England (even if they’ve been sent there from a commissioner in Wales, Scotland or elsewhere) and/or information about people in inpatient services commissioned by English commissioners (even if they are sent to inpatient services in Wales, Scotland or elsewhere). My feeling is we need to know both, and co-operation with other areas of the UK is needed to get a better overall picture if Transforming Care targets for reductions are not to be gamed by commissioners and service providers.

Second, it’s going to be difficult to keep up with the proliferation of independent sector organisations providing inpatient services – the number of people with learning disabilities and/or autism in independent sector inpatient services seems to be increasing as the number of people in NHS inpatient services declines.

Third, if people with learning disabilities and/or autism do start to make increasing use of generic mental health inpatient services rather than specialist learning disabilities inpatient services, information systems will need to be able to track individuals with learning disabilities rather than people in learning disability services (and to look for people across a wider range of NHS Trusts) – a challenge to the MHLDDS and other information systems too.

Fourth, to achieve Transforming Care targets, there appear to be a number of new services being developed that to the people living in them may look a lot like an inpatient service but which are not going to be classified as such. The new-build ‘Daisy’ complex in Wiltshire (see http://www.wiltshireccg.nhs.uk/news/new-learning-disabilities-service-to-launch-in-wiltshire ), where people are to be transferred from inpatient services to a 9-bedded ‘residential home’ to be built in the grounds of a psychiatric hospital, is a prime example of this. This will not count as an inpatient unit but may well feel like one (except that people won’t be expected to ever leave).

Fifth, another crucial fuzzy boundary is between residential special schools and inpatient services. Around 160 people with learning disabilities and/or autism up to the age of 18 are reported to be in inpatient services, but it is unclear how this maps on to the number of people in residential special schools. Knowing about these schools is a really important part of any strategy that is serious about preventing young people going into inpatient services in the first place, as a recent excellent research review by Nick Gore and colleagues on residential schools makes abundantly clear http://sscr.nihr.ac.uk/PDF/ScopingReviews/SR10.pdf ).



The last point I want to make is my personal biggest reason for wanting to keep the Learning Disability Census, and it isn’t about tracking the number of people in inpatient services. My reason is that the Learning Disability Census is the only place that gives us any regular, large-scale information on what happens to people in inpatient services – restraint, seclusion, assaults, and antipsychotic medication usage. Losing this information would give us no way of scrutinising what inpatient services are doing to people (Transforming Care aims to retain around half of the current number of inpatient places), which to me is an essential part of evaluating the impact of the Transforming Care programme.

27 comments:

  1. Is it also liable to miss out people with Learning Disabilities who are admitted to Mental Health Wards. Perhaps this is the reason for the otherwise puzzling inclusion of Norfolk and Suffolk Mental Health Trust. I know Cornwall Partnership NHS Foundation Trust completed the LD census return when there happened to be in-patients with LD on that day. Cornwall has no dedicated LD beds and uses only generic MH beds for new admissions of people with LD. It also had very few people in out of area hospitals when I last looked though I am due to repeat the audit. People tended to move through the MH beds much more quickly than they do through specialist LD A&T units but the care they got on the wards was not always well suited to their needs. If the preferred option for those people with LD and either mental health needs or challenging behaviour so severe that the MHA must be used is generic Mental Health beds, these beds must be looked at. Will the MLDDS data set collect this information? I'd say that people with LD in Mental Health wards, which may or may not have made reasonable adjustments to their disabilities, are vulnerable in all kinds of ways and that you ought not to be excluding them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Jane. Yes, agree entirely - think this was me not expressing myself very well? What I was surprised by was that Norfolk & Suffolk Mental Health Trust wasn't already in the MHLDDS list - absolutely we should be able to track people with learning disabilities in general mental health inpatient services.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As you know Chris, we've submitted an FOI to Suffolk CCGs - we've included information relating to people with learning disabilities who have been placed in mental health facilities. The campaign re the crisis in mental health service in Norfolk and Suffolk has been highlighting issues relating to Norfolk and Suffolk Mental Health NHS Trust but hasn't separated out any issues specifically relating to people with learning disabilities. See http://norfolksuffolkmentalhealthcrisis.org.uk

    ReplyDelete
  4. This allows the man or woman afflicted Relaxphin through pressure to regulate his/her state of mind. mainly, one's intellectual nation may be altered so that the emotional reactions that yield pressure are "transformed" to specific emotions. For more ==== >>>>>> http://boostupmuscles.com/relaxphin/

    ReplyDelete
  5. you have to locate the Juggernox right stability among heavy, tough, muscle-taxing weight and the use of workout execution and technique it really is desirable enough to hit the centered muscle group. this will take some time and exercise-however you may not.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.healthsupreviews.com/juggernox/

    ReplyDelete
  6. your construct muscle exercising. Trigger XL Any time you sense your muscles are not reacting to the pressure of the weights you are the use of, it is time to step them up. simply preserve in thoughts, that the ache your muscle groups feel method they may be.For more ==== >>>>>> http://boostupmuscles.com/trigger-xl/

    ReplyDelete
  7. you could also use a combination Satin Youth Cream of aloe vera and honey to get young searching pores and skin. you could additionally employ herbal treatments like cucumber juice and turmeric powder to get powerful end result. whilst searched, you can discover.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/satin-youth-cream/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Besides cellphone consultation it Penetrex Male Enhancement has commenced imparting online scientific consultations to its patients worldwide. For this purpose it has recruited numerous educated Unani medical doctors who will be offering free session to sufferers.For more ==== >>>>>> http://boostupmuscles.com/penetrex-male-enhancement/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Plus, more and more Brick Muscle women are coming to remember that will surgical procedure and implants for breast upgrades are extraordinarily evident. moreover, breast augmentation surgical treatment consists of a remarkable deal of pain plus.For more ==== >>>>>> http://www.strongtesterone.com/brick-muscle/

    ReplyDelete
  10. Follow up when you have Juggernox potential new downline members. You want to get them while they are still intrigued. Always be accessible to answer questions. If you don't act fast, they may forget all about you.

    http://www.tophealthbuy.com/juggernox/

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am 43 and experience the tricky effects of battered womens issue. I have been utilizing this for a few weeks, I can see improvments in my talk and I am set up to react to stretch out in a less energized kind of way.

    I got this thing for my mom who has dementia in light of overmedication of statin meds (Crestor especially). Her comprehension has redesignd; regardless, she had a little issue with urinary incontinence. Cognidepth's ideal to develop the estimations after some time since I think giving her 3 pills a day was an expansive measure at first. The pills are expansive and unequal, in any case it's the standard thing I've found that contains choline, uridine, and DHA, the three supplements that a MIT contemplate found to overhaul cerebrum neural affiliations.

    I discovered Cognitex around a year prior and both my life embellishment and I see the refinement. On days when I carelessness to take it, I tell my life relate I feel "disproportionate". Completely kept up paying little personality to the cost to keep up a making cerebrum!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Close to the rebranding, Cognishie

    GABA is a nootropic that has gone under a huge amount of examination beginning late. Distinctive now expecting that GABA encounters genuine burdens the blood-mind deterrent that the required estimation would be in wealth of anything a standard sort 00 case could hold. The best way to deal with oversee goad GABA to have it transported as Picamilon – that is GABA and B3 Niacin engaged. These specific the opposite side of the BBB allowing GABA to do its work. Aside for GABA Cognishield's formula is totally solid!

    Sulbutiamine is a sweet wire in Cognishield and a nootropic much like Noopept in that it is constantly discharged, on account of its high cost. Anything in the level of 500mg and over is inclined to comprehend an astounding effect, for instance, upgrade perspective by influencing the Dopamine neurotransmitter, help mental limits, for occu
    Not knowing the clear number of milligrams of Sulbutiamine in Cognishield makes it hard to study the measure of the above is truly occasion, and what whole is a precarious effect for those that swear by it. Yet again, we get the slant that the get-together of understudies behind Cognishield know their stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  13. While blended, you'll get the impetus implications of espresso without the irritating undesirable symptoms like improved circulatory strain, nervousness, and insufficient resting. These successive undesirable impacts of Intelligence RX are killed from the ltheanine, which besides gives to enhance mindfulness (past what espresso may ordinarily give). Proposed Dosage: 200mg L-theanine or 100mg three-times each day with respect to nootropic picks up that are normal. To find the results that are ideal, consider a quarter century espresso utilizing day doses a half-hour before anybody convey. Having staying away from perspectives that could realize scholarly decay for monitoring head work the best strategy begins.

    Intelligence RX, the All-Natural Brain Enhancement Supplement

    Produced using All Natural Nutrients Over 14 Million Capsules Sold

    Clinically Proven to Improve Focus and Energy No Caffeine, No Gluten and Non-GMO Ingredients

    Appeared to Help Support Memory

    also, Concentration Increases Processing Speed and Brain
    Work in Healthy Adults

    Stephen Hawking Petition | http://www.probioticspotency.com/intelligence-rx/

    ReplyDelete
  14. Instructions to De-push With Chamomile!
    All through human presence, push was really an advantageous event. Stretch kept us alive, and kept us looking for approaches to survive. Indeed, even today, there is such thing as great hassles and awful burdens. Be that as it may, we infrequently get ourselves stuck in an awful push cycle. It feels like steady stressing, dissatisfactions, and maybe you wind up getting debilitated constantly. Chamomile Calm Anti-Stress Supplements can help you advance a stretch free way of life. What's more, without the terrible kind of stretch penetrating your each idea, your body and brain will really work better and all the more effectively. For more data, simply tap the picture!

    A ton of mental vitality goes into being worried. What's more, push is really the main source of weariness. So in the event that you could dispose of a considerable measure of your every day stresses, simply consider the measure of vitality you'll need to complete things. Life gets to be less demanding, and work turns out to be more proficient when you have less stretch. Chamomile Calm All Natural Calming Blend can genuinely give you significant serenity. What's more, the recipe has the science to back these cases. Fixings like chamomile and valerian actuate quiet and can even help with tension. To take in more about what Chamomile Calm can accomplish for you, simply tap the catch beneath!

    ReplyDelete

  15. The expansive social event who are encountering issues like memory hardship, nonappearance of tremendousness, focus, center, character shadowiness, tiredness along these lines on this repairing can in like way Inteligen
    make an inescapable than ordinary structure between the neurotransmitters. It works basic making your tornado sound.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Blueberry remove

    Vitamin B12

    Acetyl-l-carnitine

    panax ginseng

    It doesn't contain any ION Z
    hurtful item furthermore tried by numerous researchers in master labs and reasoned that it is ok for use by any client.

    ReplyDelete
  17. My partner recommended me to endeavor this. Besides, ought to state it was no not precisely a blessing, that came in my life. It worked amazingly, giving me the likelihood to perform doing what needs to be done before my assistant. The results came up well ordered, be that as it may it was worth paying off. Finally, it helped me in awing and satisfying my assistant. Consequently, saving my relationship from going into decay. In case every one of you are Viarexin
    encountering an indistinguishable misery from I did, its chance to leave that shame with Viarexin I can promise you that there is no ideal course of action over this.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Is it correct to state this is Regular P3nis Development Arrangement Truly For You?
    Blackcore Edge

    Men who are scanning for a trademark isolating choice to surgery, p3nis pumps and grouped contraptions which can fight, crazy and offensive, should in reality explore this imagine.

    https://blackcoreedgetry.wordpress.com/2016/12/13/blackcore-edge/

    ReplyDelete
  19. What to would in case you get a kick out of the chance to heighten your penis measure with a particular last objective to satisfy your better half, what elective do you have to enhance your penis width and edges reviewing the finished focus to bring some intensity, control, drive to your sexual synchronization? Is it bona fide that you are Viarexin
    looking for a solution for your little penis so you can turbo-blame your nighttimes for your lace with a stone-hard penis amplifying that does not contract and will have your correct hand requesting extra?

    ReplyDelete
  20. By the time the fire brain appeared recently in the business sector that the time was GenBrain
    by no means the nerves of the only one who agreed to the recommendation of this Annex promoter brain of individuals who suffer the misfortune of memory, lack of a central difficulty concentrating, and low IQ in the brain and innovation from scratch on the grounds that they had no confidence in him.
    http://www.fitnessbites.org/genbrain

    ReplyDelete
  21. When I got to keep an Nutrapal Pro
    eye out for the status of my sales, the chairman imparted that "my sales had been crossed out." I didn't wipe out the requesting, yet by one means or another the sales was drop. The affiliation didn't predict giving me a markdown either. I anticipated that would come back to two or three times before I could get a 100% discount. The client association director said that she could refund 15% of my cash. When I urged her that I was reporting them to the BBB, she speedily set apart down 100% of my cash and drop my record. I am going to report them to the BBB in light of the way that their practices are beguiling. I am thankful to be finished with that affiliation. Thusly, BUYERS BEWARE!!!

    ReplyDelete

  22. I have blended thoughts on Nutrapal Pro, first I heard the notice on the radio about free then it turns out not being free pay for movement and after that they will auto send you for 69.99 so by then I Nutrapal Pro
    said neglecting with regards to the entire thing, (I SHOULD HAVE LISTENED TO MY INSTINCTS, )Then a head gets on and says we will send you a 30 days supply for 19.99 transportation included so I gave it a shot...

    ReplyDelete
  23. More particularly, you should anticipate to bridegroom your hairs centered on the following aspects.

    1. What enhances your encounter the best
    Legendary Beard

    Shape of your head

    Beards and moustaches designs - Learn how to form your face hair
    Image Courtesy: reddit.com/mrrrie
    The form of your face plays a very part not only on your looks but also on the way your hairs is presented.

    http://www.supplementsoffer.com/legendary-beard

    ReplyDelete
  24. MY BOOTY POP IS FULL O' POOP
    Booty pop

    Blac Chyna and her big ass jumped into bed with an ass-enhancing product ... a lot of people think is just a fake ass scam.
    Chyna posted an ad promoting Booty Pop, a spray that claims to be an "All Natural Booty Enhancer." The endorsement was fleeting ... she deleted the post almost immediately -- perhaps because the company is bombing with the Better Business Bureau.
    http://www.skinliftsup.com/apex-booty-pop-scam

    ReplyDelete

  25. Buying Booty Pop Cream

    To buy your package of Booty Pop Cream, visBooty Pop operate site of the item and position the transaction by filling up the internet type. Apply coupon code to get discount.

    Booty Pop Review: Finally, an item has been discovered which could give our grows a ideal style. Using Booty Pop, we can can be useful for the reduction of fat from our grows. Booty Pop grants Booty Pop a appropriate look. Booty Pop way the serum contributes in creating our determine curvaceous. Booty Pop is also believed to be a self-confidence enhancer and to know why, read below!

    http://www.fitnessbites.org/lift-your-buttocks

    ReplyDelete

  26. Neurofuse skilled for:

    Focus lessen. Neurofuse
    get from milk creatures like minds seems to renovation attention, tongue cutoff focuses, and memory in creating those with decreasing considering boundaries. It isn't known spending little regard to whether the later stock, which are designed with soy and clothes, can have the deficiently depicted identification ruining place. Regardless, creating acceptance plant-mulled over phosphatidylserine improvements memory in individuals who have age-related memory hardship.

    Alzheimer's sickness. Taking phosphatidylserine can renovation some the symptoms and performances of Alzheimer's disease problem getting after 6-12 a few weeks of therapy. It has every one of the shops of being handiest in those with less inciting symptoms and reactions.


    http://www.stressfreebrains.com/neurofuse-elite/

    ReplyDelete
  27. RenuGlow Advanced Serum :- Our epidermis is incredibly fragile and thin and has a tendency to get even more delicate as we mature. After all, this is what all anti-aging creams are intended for. We are usually advised to use an anti-aging lotion after crossing the age of 30. But have you ever wondered why they say so? Well, it is because the age of 30 is that crucial part of your daily lifestyle where your epidermis begins changing gradually. It is your 30s when you discover the first ageing symptoms on your epidermis. These ageing symptoms could be anything like collections and wrinkles, collections and wrinkles, crow’s legs, age areas, under eye sectors, sagginess, etc. RenuGlow Advanced In fact, we usually discover out the first ageing symptoms and symptoms of the human body around our sight, which happens to be the most delicate parts of the epidermis. According to the studies, all this happens because of the shortage of an essential protein in the epidermis which begins decreasing after a certain point of age. This protein is known as bovine collagen and is produced normally by the epidermis tissues. When the development begins falling, the epidermis begins losing its organic flexibility and stiffness to cause the sagginess, bloating, and wrinkling of the epidermis.
    http://dietplanusa.com/secret-allure-cream/renuglow/

    ReplyDelete