Tuesday 10 November 2015

We don't need no consultation


Lately, I find myself turning more and more to the Devil’s Dictionary by Ambrose Bierce (a late 19th century American rabble rousing journalist and writer) – see http://www.thedevilsdictionary.com/  for an online version. On the day the Department of Health published its response to their consultation “No voice unheard, no right ignored”, I found this Devil’s Dictionary entry:

Consult, v.i. To seek another’s approval of a course already decided on

The sad thing this, applying this to the Department of Health consultation response feels like a bit of a compliment, unless ‘the course of action already decided on’ includes ‘doing as little as possible’. This blogpost won’t be a comprehensive look at the consultation response (can I call it NVUNRI, which any fan of Shooting Stars will know how to pronounce) – others are better placed than me to do this well and it has been handily summarised by @AndyMcNicoll…



Instead, this blogpost will contain some random reflections, in particular doing a bit of good ol’ comparing and contrasting (those student essays burn deep…) with the consultation process and response for Valuing People Now. Valuing People Now (VAPENOW?), let’s remember, is only six years old, and has never to my knowledge been officially superseded by any overarching policy for (with?) people with learning disabilities since.

A declaration of interest here – at Lancaster University we analysed the responses to the Valuing People Now consultation – although my beef isn’t largely with the way the NVUNRI has been analysed and reported (this was also done by an independent agency, The Evidence Centre). Instead my beef is with the half-hearted way in which the Department of Health ‘promoted’ the consultation, and the political uses to which the consultation has been put.

The Valuing People Now consultation (see here for the report analysing what people said http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20130107105354/http://www.dh.gov.uk/prod_consum_dh/groups/dh_digitalassets/documents/digitalasset/dh_093362.pdf ) gained in total 2,009 useable responses, including: 730 from people with learning disabilities; 407 from family members; 375 from professionals; and 375 from ‘others’. The report analysing the NVUNRI consultation (see here https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/475153/summary_of_responses_acc.pdf ) gained 468 responses, of which ‘half’ were from people with learning disabilities and families, which a maximum of 389 responses to any individual question. Clearly, the Department of Health didn’t put nearly as much effort into encouraging people to give their opinions this time around.

The numbers of people responding to the NVUNRI consultation start to look perilously small, particularly when they are broken down into the views of different groups of people who may have different perspectives (people with learning disabilities vs large voluntary sector organisations, for example). Only the consultation analysis, and DH’s consultation response, doesn’t do this. Although we could have done a much better job of the Valuing People Now consultation analysis, particularly in terms of including people with learning disabilities and family members in the analysis, we did feel it was crucial to represent the views of people with learning disabilities, family members, and professionals separately.

Instead, throughout the DH response there is a general air of ‘some people said this, other people said that’, which is used to justify inaction or a bit more pondering. Well, which people said this and which people said that? Who is more important to listen to? What about doing what’s right?

Whatever our collectively jaundiced views on government rhetoric, the shrinkage of ambition from Valuing People Now (see http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20130107105354/http://www.dh.gov.uk/prod_consum_dh/groups/dh_digitalassets/documents/digitalasset/dh_093375.pdf ) to NVUNRI (see https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/475155/Gvt_Resp_Acc.pdf ) is striking, even in the ministerial forewords - always a good indicator of whether the civil service machinery is signed up to a policy. Words are cheap (a lesson I know well!) but compare and contrast these snippets from the forewords – (1) is from Valuing People Now and (2) is from NVUNRI:

1)      People with learning disabilities are entitled to the same aspirations and life chances as other people.
2)      Our vision of a civilised society is one in which we take more responsibility for ourselves and our neighbours as part of thriving communities working together, and with less dependence on remote bureaucracies.

1)      But although we have made real progress, there is still a lot to do – and that is why we are restating our commitment to leading change to transform people’s lives and opportunities.
2)      One area where we are still not making enough progress to realise our vision is for those with learning disabilities, autism and mental ill health.

1)      This Government is determined to deliver equality and independent living for all disabled people.
2)      Our aim is that people lead as fulfilling and independent lives as they can, and that they have the support to live independently when possible.

1)      Moreover, we recognise that people with learning disabilities are among the groups most often excluded from society. That is why we have made it a priority across government to support more people with learning disabilities into real jobs and settled homes.
2)      For some people, being in employment will be a key indicator of success.

1)      The strategy and the delivery plan which is published alongside it set out the action we plan to take over the next three years, working with people with learning disabilities, their families and carers and with other partners.
2)      That is why you will find that this response is phased so that we can make progress urgently by building on existing momentum and implementing change quickly as well as setting out a longer term plan that will tackle some of the most difficult and complex challenges.

1)      The strategy focuses on what needs to be done at all levels to deliver the vision of equality and transformed lives for everyone.
2)      The package of proposals we set out here is intended to enable system-wide changes that make it easier to do the right thing for people and their families.

1)      If people with learning disabilities and their carers are to have the same opportunities as other people in society and to lead a fulfilling life, we need to improve their access to the whole range of public services.
2)      Many people and organisations at all levels have key parts to play in making our vision happen. At the local level, Health and Wellbeing Boards need to ensure they have good plans to tackle the challenges ahead.

1)      It means taking a human rights-based approach.
2)      As a country, a key measure of our success will be how we care for the weakest and most vulnerable in our communities.

To be honest, I feel a bit torn about presenting these comparisons – perhaps the replacement of overblown rhetoric with a bit of becoming modesty about doing practical, achievable stuff within a realistic timeframe is a good thing? Well, I’d be more convinced about this if there was a convincing, practical plan on the horizon. For all the consultation response’s grand talk about Implementation Phases 1, 2 and 3 (although they’re not sequential, you understand?):
·        Implementation Phase 1 seems to be mainly corralling stuff that is already happening (some of this is good stuff that’s worth doing, but timescales are not attached), although the DH should have learned from the Winterbourne View saga that ‘guidance’ rarely has the Cillit Bang effect on commissioners and services already under the cosh and past caring what the government tells them to do;
·        Implementation  Phase 2 is waiting to see whether any fiddling with the Mental Health Act will be recommended to the government from the Law Commission; and
·        Implementation Phase 3, “which explores more radical solutions to longer-term issues, as well as ongoing monitoring and review, and a commitment that the Government will intervene further, including through legislation if necessary, if the improvements sought continue not to be realised in practice.”

Implementation Phase 3 is curious, a kind of “You don’t feel well? Come back and see me when it’s developed into a full-blown health crisis and then we might do something” vibe. This doesn’t come close to understanding the reality of the lives of so many people with learning disabilities, how this is likely to be getting worse rather than better, and the urgency of doing something radical about it now (#LBBill anyone? https://lbbill.wordpress.com/ ).

It also doesn’t seem to realise that the information the government is collecting that could be used to ‘monitor’ the situation is getting worse rather than better in relation to people with learning disabilities (at least, the information that is made publicly available). For example, less information than in previous years can be specifically examined for people with learning disabilities regarding safeguarding referrals and their consequences and Deprivation of Liberty Safeguarding processes. There is no specific publicly available information about people with learning disabilities at all that I can find in DWP statistics (I would love to hear that I’m wrong on this). Significant numbers of commissioners and local authorities don’t bother to provide information on important policy priorities, such as the number of people with learning disabilities in inpatient services. People with learning disabilities are rapidly disappearing from official sight (and from a responsibility to be supported), both within education and adult social services (see http://chrishatton.blogspot.co.uk/2015/11/the-disappeared.html ). And the DH have not had the commitment to drive through mandatory reporting of deaths of people with learning disabilities in services, surely the most fundamental ‘monitoring’ indicator there is.


It just doesn’t feel enough.

44 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The very next entry after CONSULT in the Devil’s Dictionary is:

    CONTEMPT, n. The feeling of a prudent man for an enemy who is too formidable safely to be opposed.

    I am certainly feeling it towards the bureaucrats massaging figures and watering down reports to hide suffering so that laws can be passed relieving the fortunate and well off of any moral duty.

    Keep blogging to redress it!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is generic writing process. Creative and impressive in nature. However, your writing is not useful for students wishing to get some tips on their academic writing. These students search Dissertation Writing Service for assistance when they see no aid from writing process. Essay Writing Service UK

    ReplyDelete
  4. People with learning abilities feel a lot of difficulty in their lives to carry on their career and making changes in their lives. All we should do is to motivate them and aspire to learn and grow facing all the difficulties in life. Essay UK Writers

    ReplyDelete
  5. Our vision towards creating our society in which we proceed with more accountability for ourselves and our neighbours as part of prosperous societies functioning together, and with less requirements of remote governments.Cheap Assignment UK

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nice post. thanks for sharing this information with us.
    Professional Dissertation Writers UK

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is such a professional blog. It really help me a lot. Keep it up.
    UK Reviews on Assignment Writing

    ReplyDelete
  8. Incredible blog. I am very much impressed by it. Keep sharing.
    Professional Assignment Help by UK

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great post. Thanks for sharing your good thoughts. Keep it up.
    Standard Essay for University

    ReplyDelete
  10. This website is providing the fantastic info is visible in this blog and new technology is visible in this blog.

    http://www.cosmopolitanmechanical.ca/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Congrats on having such well managed site! It has good looks and contains informative content as well. We are also a web portal where students get the help with the academic writing by opting for our assignment help online and can get a well written assignment.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Decided exclusively by perusers' fill-in-the-clear reactions, the honors you'll discover on these pages name the merchants that give the best innovation in classes from programming and frameworks to instrumentation and last control components. Write my Assignment

    ReplyDelete
  13. Well these are some noteworthy stuff, I would love to play these all recreations, can hardly wait to get my hands on it, a few moves are baffling particularly in auto dashing diversions, on the off chance that you can set up the guide that how to control and some uncommon tricks of the amusement that'd be even much better. www.researchpapertown.com

    ReplyDelete
  14. Aw, this was an amazingly pleasant post. Finding the time and real push to make a decent article however what would i be able to state I put things off a ton and never figure out how to complete anything. Write My Assignment

    ReplyDelete
  15. It is good to see such a helpful website! It has informative as well as interesting articles. I look forward to visit this site again and again. Students with the assignment writing problem could visit our site and can opt for our assignment writing help.

    ReplyDelete
  16. what a great article that is, i really impressed from your article. i you want to know about plastic surgery, you can visit here benefits of plastic surgery .

    ReplyDelete
  17. I Appreciate This Work Amazing Post For Us I Like It.
    Crypto Technical Analysis

    ReplyDelete
  18. John Arnold Is An Academic Writer Of The Dissertation-Guidance. Who Writes Quality Academic Papers For Students To Help Them In Accomplishing Their Goals.
    Homework on Engineering

    ReplyDelete

  19. Nice Content Written
    Just wow author, I was looking for the same topic, which you just provided me in your content
    Keep writing and nice article again
    Kudos!
    movie streaming!
    Watch Movies !
    donwnloadshowbox!

    ReplyDelete
  20. This post is not just informative but impressive also. The post is so convincing that it created an urge to choose Dissertation Writing Services. You can email us at info@ukdissertationhelp.co.uk or Phone Number: 020 8144 9988.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Excellent information Providing by your Article, thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice article. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists. Kindly visit livewebtutors website we providing best assignment help services in Australia.
    Read more now :- nursing Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  22. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  23. For all my checking just as printing works whether in office or at home, I generally like to utilize HP printer. Be that as it may, because of certain causes, I am confronting loads of issues identified with my HP printer and don't have the foggiest idea how to end them. Along these lines, I simply need to realize that, would I be able to confide in 123.hp.com/setup to fix my issues which are related with my HP printer.
    HP Printer in Error State
    Printer Customer Care
    BLOG

    ReplyDelete
  24. The most challenging thing in student life is when you run out of money and it’s the start or middle of the running month and you have to do a lot of things related to your studies especially when you have to hire assignment writing service provider for your academic writing. Keeping this in mind our Academic Writing Experts provides the best rates in Australia.
    assignmenthelp

    ReplyDelete
  25. I have a long desire to travel Nepal Tour Package once in the whole life. Now, I am planning a short Nepal Tour Packages with my family.
    Nepal Tourism Package
    Nepal Tourist Packages

    ReplyDelete
  26. Very informative and well written post! Quite interesting and nice topic chosen for the post. MyAssignmentHelpAu has been a pioneer within the Best Assignment Help online services and within the Australia and different countries ceaselessly for over Seven years. Make an order now for professional work, delivered on time and pure.

    ReplyDelete
  27. By far the best influencers of our generation. Beautiful idea. Love the random reflections to get framed but never thought about consultation. Cheap dissertation writing services

    ReplyDelete
  28. I hold an extended experience within the accounting and financial field and have extensive knowledge of various modules and versions of QuickBooks accounting software. And although my purpose is simply to entitle you with the simplest possible solutions associated with QuickBooks. I hold specialization find and resolving error based solutions to your problems. If you've got QuickBooks with different error codes including QuickBooks Error 3371, getting into touch with us will allow you to find the proper solutions to your problems. Luckily, I’m available all the time to supply the real–time assistance to the needy users.

    ReplyDelete
  29. You had me engaged by reading and you know what? I want to read more about that. That's what's used as an amusing post.
    read more:- APA Referencing Generator

    ReplyDelete
  30. Jessy this side, if you are doing regular windstream email login, you surely face some technical login issues and you need online Windstream tech support. So, instead of wandering casually, simply put a call at 844-300-0168.

    windstream login

    windstream net email login

    windstream net login

    www windstream net email login

    ReplyDelete
  31. Welcome to Emiran HealthCare Our services are aimed at ensuring that our clients can remain at home, receiving the highest care standard, yet without having distortion or disturbance in their comfort ability.

    Domiciliary Care
    Community Care
    HealthCare Provider
    Support living care
    Live in care


    Contact us:

    Call: 01908299170

    Email :info@emiranhealthcare.co.uk
    Website: https://emiranhealthcare.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  32. Thank you for your outstanding article. You will always find clients coming back to us which is a result of our excellent services. Our goal is to offer unique and specialized services to our clients and in return create a long-lasting working relationship. We provide the Best Residential Projects in Greater Noida West 2/3/4 BHK Flats, Apartments, Penthouse, Corporate Properties, Commercial Properties in Noida, Greater Noida West, Delhi NCR with Great Discount and Deals. Learn more about from Investmango website. visit call now :- +918595189189 , 7428189189

    ReplyDelete
  33. Thank you for your outstanding article. You will always find clients coming back to us which is a result of our excellent services. Our goal is to offer unique and specialized services to our clients and in return create a long-lasting working relationship. We provide the Best Godrej South Estate and 2/3/4 BHK Flats, Apartments, Penthouse, Corporate Properties, Commercial Properties in Noida, Greater Noida West, Delhi NCR with Great Discount and Deals. Learn more about from Investmango website. visit call now :- +918076042671

    ReplyDelete
  34. This must be a popular blog. Thank you for sharing such an informative article. Are you having problems to write an excellent CIPD assignment? Assignment Help is the only solution to let go of your difficulties in minutes. We are the qualified assistant to deal with your high-level CIPD assignments by pouring in our efforts to let you present the best of the writing. CIPD is just not a professional qualification but a ladder to experience the professional avenues that guarantee to take you to your desired destination. Read more on on CIPD Assignment Help AE .

    ReplyDelete
  35. Let’s Start! As we know, Amazon Prime Video is one of the best apps for watching web series and movies on the app. For more info visit -
    activate amazon mytv
    activate amazon mytv
    activate amazon mytv
    activate amazon mytv
    activate amazon mytv
    activate amazon mytv

    ReplyDelete
  36. We will ensure that the urgent assignment journalists complete your forthcoming assignments quickly. In the event that you buy in to the free SMS alarms offices, you can monitor the advancement. Regardless, you will get moment assignment help directly in your inbox a long time before the cutoff time you set at the hour of putting in the request. more- cheap assignment help , write my assignment

    ReplyDelete
  37. Acadecraft has proven experience in the field of instructional designing services. Our creative instructional designer as well as freelance instructional designing provider are keen to provide their best skills for various means.

    ReplyDelete

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.