Monday, 23 March 2020

COVID-19, people with learning disabilities, and NICE Guideline 159 on critical care

Excuse me for this extremely hastily written blogpost - hope some people will find it useful.

NICE (the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence) has just produced a rapid guideline for health professionals on what to do about critical care for people with the COVID-19 coronavirus. Among other things, NICE write clinical guidelines that everyone in health services in England are supposed to follow, so a guideline on this is a big deal. Its basic premise is that there will be a shortage of critical care (intensive care) services in the face of the number of people with COVID-19 who would ordinarily use them, so the guideline is to help health professionals make decisions about who to admit to critical care or not. Horrible, horrible decisions for a health professional to have to make - although these decisions are having to be made due to a shortage of sufficient services and health professionals.

The guideline NG 159 is relatively short and is available here, and in this post I want to quickly outline some potential implications for people with learning disabilities if they get COVID-19 and need to go to hospital (of course, many people, even if they get COVID-19, won;t need hospital treatment and will recover).

The starting point of the guideline is that "On admission to hospital, assess all adults for frailty, irrespective of age and COVID-19 status. Consider comorbidities and underlying health conditions".

'Frailty' is an idea that has typically grown around older people generally and people with dementia specifically, where the purpose is to try and predict who will be more likely to experience things like hospitalisation and rapid deterioration in their health from a set of 'markers', although there is apparently little consensus between measures or markers of 'frailty'.

It is not clear to me (even if people coming to hospital with COVID-19 will be mainly older people) why frailty is the essential thing to assess people for - there are fundamental ethical issues here which others are much better placed than me to comment on.

In this more limited post, there is really no evidence that any frailty measure is applicable to adults across the age range, including people with learning disabilities. [And there no mention in the guideline on children - while the assumption may be that few children with COVID-19 will potentially need critical care the potential health impact on children with learning disabilities and multiple health conditions is not yet clear. Hospitals need to be ready and prepared for this eventuality].

And the consequences of the blanket application of a frailty measure in these circumstances for people with learning disabilities worry me greatly.

First, the scale that NICE says should be used is the Clinical Frailty Scale, developed for people with dementia, that has 9 levels (see below). This Scale strongly assumes that there is a progressive course of dementia, combining (in quite subjective ways) judgements of physical fitness, cognitive functioning, the kind of support people need, and physical health problems into these levels.






































This is, to say the least, profoundly unhelpful when applied to any group of disabled people with long-term impairments and particularly unhelpful when applied to people with learning disabilities who by definition have some issues with learning certain types of things. For example, on this scale I think anyone with profound and multiple learning disabilities would at best be rated 7 (Severely Frail) on this scale. And perhaps pretty much any adult with learning disabilities who has jumped the eligibility hurdle for long-term adult social care support (around 150,000 people in England alone) - and maybe all children with severe or profound multiple learning difficulties with an EHCP (around 40,000 children in England) - would be rated at best as 5 (Mildly Frail)?

In these guidelines, what you score on this scale (being rated by health professionals not routinely working with people with learning disabilities, working in conditions of extreme pressure, when we know that mainstream hospitals are not routinely reasonably adjusted to provide equally effective healthcare for people with learning disabilities) really, really matters.

Section 2 of the guideline (Admission to critical care) is where the main work of the guideline is done. After completed and recording the Clinical Frailty Scale score, the health professional should "Discuss the risks, benefits and possible likely outcomes of the different treatment options with patients, families and carers using decision support tools (where available) so that they can make informed decisions about their treatment wherever possible)." Questions:
1) As far as I can see, none of the materials linked to are designed for use with people with learning disabilities, and there are no references to making reasonable adjustments to this process.
2) Given people's circumstances it is possible that a person with learning disabilities may be admitted to hospital without a member of their family allowed to be with them, and paid carers may be filling in and not know the person well.
3) Capacity is not even mentioned here.
4) The person is likely to be greatly distressed at this point.

Then, the critical care team will discuss whether to admit the person to critical care or not if...
"where the CFS score suggests the person is less frail (for example the score is less than 5) [the for example is doing a lot of work here], they are likely to benefit from critical care organ support and they want critical treatment, or..."
"the CFS score suggests the person is more frail (for example the score is 5 or more), there is uncertainty regarding the likely benefit of critical care organ support, and critical care advice is needed to help the decision about treatment".

People with learning disabilities are unlikely to come out of these discussions with the critical care team well, given the CFS predisposes people to be rated as being frail and the greater likelihood of people being acquiescent to suggestions put to them by health professionals in a position of authority at a time of great stress.

Then, if you get through that, health professionals should "Take into account the impact of underlying pathologies, comorbidities and severity of acute illness on the likelihood of critical care treatment achieving the desired outcome".

How will a health professional make this accounting? Well, if they're going on government guidance on social distancing for COVID-19 they will notice that people with learning disabilities are already listed as a 'chronic neurological condition' and therefore part of a group "who are at increased risk of severe illness from coronavirus (COVID-19)" and therefore should be "particularly stringent in following social distancing measures". Does this then mean that all people with learning disabilities by definition have an "underlying pathology"? And it is the case that various groups of people with learning disabilities are more likely to have relevant health conditions such as respiratory health problems, heart problems and diabetes. Will this tilt health professionals away from thinking that critical care treatment is likely to achieve the desired outcome for people with learning disabilities?

Assuming that this means you won't get critical care, what happens to you? The next step according to the guideline is to "Support non-critical healthcare professionals to discuss treatment plans with patients who would not benefit from critical care treatment or who do not wish to be admitted to critical care." Note that from an irrelevant assessment of frailty and an assessment of potential risk factors we are now at the point of apparent certainty about "patients who would not benefit from critical care treatment." And as I mentioned earlier, will people with learning disabilities be assertive enough in this situation to demand critical care for themselves?

Health professionals should also "Sensitively discuss a possible 'do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation' decision (with all adults with capacity) and CFS score suggestive of increased frailty (for example of 5 or more)." There is no mention of what should happen with people without capacity, or of reasonably adjusted ways to discuss these issues with people.

Finally in Section 2, health professionals should "ensure that when treatment outside critical care is the agreed course of action, patients receive optimal care within the ward". What 'optimal care' consists of is not specified.

There is more to the guideline that I won't go into here, but the general direction of travel that stacks the deck against people with learning disabilities is reinforced and replicated throughout. This guideline is not fit for purpose for people with learning disabilities.


UPDATE: NICE have issued the following 'clarification' about this guideline.


This is welcome - it will be important to know what (if anything) the CFS will be replaced with. It is also vital to understand what NICE plans for other groups of disabled people (and in fact, anyone who isn't an older person). Most of my questions in the blogpost about how the guideline will operate in practice, and their implications for how people with learning disabilities are treated (or not) remain.




71 comments:

  1. Thank you for this thoughtful blog Chris- you articulate with characteristic precision, a concern that vexes many.
    My thoughts on this-
    1. The Clinical Frailty Scale and other similar tools are meant to offer some measure of frailty in an individual in comparison to a non-frail or at least less-frail baseline. That is why it was intended for use in the over 65s with (acquired) medical conditions- typically dementia.
    2. With the unprecedented crisis of COVID 19, one has to acknowledge the need for some sort of triaging toll which has some semblance of validation and hence the Clinical Frailty Score, a tool that was intended to identify frailty in the over-65s is now recommended for all age groups.
    3. If one interprets the definitions of the 1-9 score categories in a concrete way, the vast majority of people with a learning disability will get rated as 5 or above because of the significant deficits in adaptive functioning that they have.
    4. But these scores are not meant to be allocated in that concrete way. From the time that the electronic frailty index was introduced into the GP contract a couple of years ago, it has been stressed that it is not a clinical diagnostic tool and that clinical judgment has to be a part of its use.
    (Reference: https://www.england.nhs.uk/ourwork/clinical-policy/older-people/frailty/efi/#what-numbers-of-people-living-with-frailty-do-we-expect-to-be-diagnosed
    5. Hence a person with mild or moderate learning disability who may have some adaptive function deficits, but has no acquired active medical conditions may well in your clinical judgment be rated as a 2 or 3 rather than 5 or 6. The same could apply for people with more severe degrees of learning disability too. The situation becomes complicated if there are serious and limiting additional physical illnesses which co-exist with the learning disability and in those cases, you may well end up with a higher frailty score. Some guidance on that would be welcome.
    6. In all this, one has to stress the importance of clinical judgment, being part of the scoring process so that people with learning disability are not just automatically scored as 5 or above.
    7. It is worth remembering that when the electronic frailty index was introduced, the numbers of people with severe frailty expected to be identified nationally was 291,170 (3% of the over 65s). https://www.england.nhs.uk/ourwork/clinical-policy/older-people/frailty/efi/#what-numbers-of-people-living-with-frailty-do-we-expect-to-be-diagnosed It is clear that just categorizing everyone with a learning disability into that category was never the intention and clinicians using their judgment can still make sure that remains the case.

    Regi T Alexander
    http://beltonandbrowston.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VVApril2020W.pdf

    ReplyDelete
  2. webroot.com/safe visit the Webroot website to download your Webroot antivirus product and also get Webroot Installation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. To enact Hulu Plus on your gadget, either utilize the on-screen console to enter your Hulu sign in data or go to and enter the gadget initiation code. hulu.com/activate Both of these strategies will enable you to utilize Hulu on any Hulu-upheld gadget.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Driving viewership to an unheard of level How to actuate or setup Roku com gadget?. roku.com/link We all realize that the Roku player accompanies some astounding highlights .

    ReplyDelete
  5. To enact Hulu Plus on your gadget, either utilize the on-screen console to enter your Hulu sign in data or go to and enter the gadget initiation code. hulu.com/activate Both of these strategies will enable you to utilize Hulu on any Hulu-upheld gadget.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Roku is a streaming device, which is a reasonable roku setup and other Set-up Box. Roku is a bundle of amusement, roku.com/link where client can stream for boundless motion appears, web arrangement, news, animation and a lot more projects.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hulu is one of the best streaming services that ease access to content on different types of devices. You can stream across computers, mobile devices and gaming consoles. However, hulu.com/activate before enjoying this service you will need to subscribe to the service and activate your Hulu account.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Do more with OneDrive and Office 365 Create polished documents, unlock insights, office.com/setup present with clarity, and collaborate in real-time using Office 365.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Roku gives the least complex approach to stream excitement to your TV. On your terms and visit roku.com/link With a great many accessible channels to look over.

    ReplyDelete
  10. After you buy Norton Antivirus visit norton.com/setup, sign in to norton account by then enter norton thing for Norton Setup or Install Norton Antivirus.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Roku gives the least complex approach to stream excitement to your TV. roku.com/link On your terms. With a great many accessible channels to look over.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Introduce mcafee item with no problem. We give best establishment administration mcafee.com/activate click here for more subtleties.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Roku gives the least complex approach to stream excitement to your TV. On your terms. enter roku activation code With a great many accessible channels to look over.

    ReplyDelete
  14. To enact Hulu Plus on your gadget, either utilize the on-screen console to enter your Hulu sign in data or go to and enter the gadget initiation code. enter hulu activation code Both of these strategies will enable you to utilize Hulu on any Hulu-upheld gadget.

    ReplyDelete
  15. install norton antivirus to protect your computer from any virus attacks.visit here norton.com/setup.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Roku is a streaming device, which is a reasonable roku setup and other Set-up Box. Roku is a bundle of amusement, where client can stream for boundless motion appears, web arrangement, roku.com/link news, animation and a lot more projects.

    ReplyDelete
  17. download the security product, and give you the best protection against online threats that won't interrupt your work by webroot.com/safe

    ReplyDelete
  18. Webroot is one of the most important and powerful applications which mainly designs to tackle harmful malware webroot.com/safe and help to secure information.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Webroot is a best-known antivirus software protects your devices against phishing, ransom attacks, viruses and malwares. visit here for more details : webroot key code activation , It can keep your data, files and essential information safe and also scan your files against online threat.

    ReplyDelete
  20. office it the package of office tools to make your working smooth and effective.office.com/myaccount Get it downloaded in your computer with the fast help.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Visit the Webroot webroot.com/safe website to download your Webroot antivirus product and also get Webroot Installation.

    ReplyDelete
  22. norton help to ensure your gadgets against antiviruses and offer security to client norton.com/setup and giving personality and contraption affirmation to your related life.

    ReplyDelete
  23. McAfee security programming offers a standout amongst the best malware insurance among the various security suites in the worldwide market. As per the most recent reports, mcafee.com/activate there has been noteworthy development in digital assaults in the course of recent years.

    ReplyDelete
  24. To stop the malware from damaging the folders on the device, McAfee Antivirus software has to be downloaded in the device. After downloading the McAfee Antivirus, mcafee.com/activate the protection for the system data automatically gets started.

    ReplyDelete
  25. norton provides industry-leading antivirus and security software for your PC, Mac .norton.com/setup and Installation Process – For both PC and mobile users.

    ReplyDelete
  26. A YouTube activation code is a is generated by the youtube app on certain devices,youtube.com/activate for eg Apple, Xbox Wii etc or other connected devices,which is done through a google account.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Download office setup 365 with the best tech help team and make your computer working with office package and click here office.com/setup

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hulu is outstanding amongst other gushing administrations that straightforwardness access to content on various sorts of gadgets. You can stream crosswise over PCs, cell phones and gaming reassures. hulu.com/activate Be that as it may, before getting a charge out of this administration you should buy in to the administration and enact your Hulu account.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Hulu is one of the best streaming services that ease access to content on different types of devices. You can stream across computers, mobile devices and gaming consoles. However, hulu.com/activate before enjoying this service you will need to subscribe to the service and activate your Hulu account.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Install webroot with premium help and best tech team and make your computer virus free - webroot.com/safe

    ReplyDelete
  31. Download webroot to remove virus from your computer with the best support team.visit here for more details :webroot.com/safe

    ReplyDelete
  32. A YouTube activation code is a is generated by the youtube app on certain devices,youtube.com/activate for eg Apple, Xbox Wii etc or other connected devices,which is done through a google account.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Install 123 HP Printer Driver, Software Downloads How to install a local printer in computer or mobile devices. Hit a Start button in your computing devices and click 123hp.com/setup a control panel on a Start menu.

    ReplyDelete
  34. To enact Hulu Plus on your gadget, hulu.com/activate either utilize the on-screen console to enter your Hulu sign in data or go to and enter the gadget initiation code. Both of these strategies will enable you to utilize Hulu on any Hulu-upheld gadget.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Visit the webroot.com/safe website to download your Webroot antivirus product and also get Webroot Installation.

    ReplyDelete
  36. mcafee antivirus is commonly used aantivirus recognizes and kill PC contamination, mcafee.com/activate the mail worms,the trojan programs,and also empowers your structure to free of disease and other malware is a critical step by step challenge. for more nuances.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Connect your Hulu Device to your TV & Insert batteries hulu.com/activate into Hulu Remote; Turn on your Hulu Device and Connect Device to the Internet.

    ReplyDelete
  38. You need a Roku record to enact your roku.com/linkgadget and access diversion. There are no month to month gear rental expenses. Including an installment technique lets you effectively lease/purchase motion pictures or buy in to well known administrations.

    ReplyDelete
  39. download the security product, and give you the best protection against online threats that won't interrupt your work by webroot.com/safe

    ReplyDelete
  40. Present norton antivirus with the best help gathering and keep your PC contamination free. norton.com/setup Download norton antivirus with the best help gathering and avoid disease attacks.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Mcafee Antivirus Download and Free Trial Security Software. mcafee.com/activate Use our 30-day groundwork to get free antivirus insurance and illness launch while you discover how McAfee can ensure your PC superior to other security thing.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Hulu supports a wide variety of hulu.com/activate devices that you can use to stream with us. You can activate any of them at any time, as well as remove them from your account

    ReplyDelete
  43. McAfee, the device to-cloud cybersecurity organizatio, mcafee.com/activate gives security courses of action that shield data and keep perils from contraption to cloud using an open, proactive, and information driven technique. Present mcafee thing with no issue. We give best establishment association.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Get help with roku.com/link com & troubleshooting, find answers to account & billing questions, and learn how to use your Roku device.

    ReplyDelete
  45. mcafee antivirus is widely used aantivirus helps to detect and neutralize computer virus, the mail worms,the trojan programs,and also helps your system free of virus and other malware is quite a daily challenge. for more details visit:mcafee.com/activate

    ReplyDelete
  46. Visit hulu website page and log in if prompted. Enterhulu.com/activate the unique activation code that is displayed on your TV screen and within 30 seconds or so you should be logged in.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Roku gives the leastroku.com/linkcomplex approach to stream excitement to your TV. With a large number of accessible channels visit here for more subtleties.

    ReplyDelete
  48. norton internet security is norton.com/setup widely used antivirus provides the easiest to use and most intutive protection for your computer and your mobiles .install it and forget about viruses,spyware,root-kits -, hackers.for more details visit today.

    ReplyDelete
  49. Roku spilling players need webroku.com/link access to stream content. They utilize remote to interface with your home system.

    ReplyDelete
  50. mcafee antivirus mcafee.com/activate is broadly utilized antivirus recognizes and kill PC infection, the infected mail ,the malware programs,and enables your framework to free of infection and other malware is a serious every day challenge.

    ReplyDelete
  51. You need a Roku record toenter roku activation code enact your gadget and access diversion. There are no month to month gear rental expenses. Including an installment technique lets you effectively lease/purchase motion pictures or buy in to well known administrations.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hulu centers enter hulu activation code principally around gushing more current TV shows and its very own unique substance over films or documentaries and offers month to month membership levels (more on this underneath) to tweak your survey involvement.

    ReplyDelete
  53. norton web security is norton.com/setup generally utilized antivirus gives the least demanding to utilize and most intutive assurance for your PC and your mobiles.Install the norton.com/setup on your Android gadget and disregard viruses,spyware,root-units, programmers.

    ReplyDelete
  54. Webroot Mobilewebroot.com/safe Security is a multi client permit enabling you to utilize your permit on up to 3 gadgets. On the off chance that you are utilizing the most extreme number of gadgets you should uninstall from the old gadget preceding introducing on the new gadget.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Webroot SecureAnywhere AntiViruswebroot.com/safe keeps watch on obscure projects until its cerebrum in the cloud goes to a judgment. It's an extremely common framework, yet testing demonstrates that it carries out the responsibility, and does it well.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Mind blowing, lightweight,webroot key code activation fused protection for PC, Mac and Android, cloud-based Webroot Internet Security Complete with antivirus guarantees singular information by thwarting the latest malware, phishing, and advanced ambushes. Visit to present webroot antivirus in your pc.

    ReplyDelete
  57. office it the heap ofoffice.com/myaccount office mechanical assemblies to make your working smooth and effective.Get it downloaded in your PC with the speedy assistance visit here for more nuances.

    ReplyDelete
  58. webroot iswebroot.com/safe a simply used software,install extreme digital security at webroot safe or at, click here to download webroot safe.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Norton Securitynorton.com/setup ensures your gadgets and the data on them, Norton Secure VPN encodes the information you send and get when utilizing open Wi-Fi.

    ReplyDelete
  60. mcafee antivirus mcafee.com/activate is broadly utilized aantivirus distinguishes and kill PC infection, the mail worms,the trojan programs,and likewise helps your framework free of infection and other malware is a significant every day challenge. for more subtleties visit today.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Activate mcafeemcafee.com/activateantivirus with the highly professional tech team and get rid of antivirus from computer click the link for more details.

    ReplyDelete
  62. norton internetnorton.com/setupsecurity is widely used antivirus provides the easiest to use and most intutive protection for your computer and your mobiles .install it and forget about viruses,spyware,root-kits -, hackers.for more details visit today.

    ReplyDelete
  63. activating youryoutube.com/activate YouTube on the devices isn’t complicated at all. But since there are many different devices that you can use, the way you activate YouTube varies from device to device. download today.

    ReplyDelete
  64. Download office 365 office.com/setup with our assistance group without completing any work independent from anyone else.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Hulu centershulu.com/activate principally around gushing more current TV shows and its very own unique substance over films or documentaries and offers month to month membership levels (more on this underneath) to tweak your survey involvement.

    ReplyDelete
  66. To actuate Hulu hulu.com/activate Plus on your gadget, either utilize the on-screen console to enter your Hulu sign in data or go to Hulu.com/enact and enter the gadget initiation code. Both of these strategies will enable you to utilize Hulu on any Hulu-upheld gadget.

    ReplyDelete
  67. Webroot SecureAnywherewebroot.com/safe AntiVirus keeps watch on obscure projects until its cerebrum in the cloud goes to a judgment. It's an extremely common framework, yet testing demonstrates that it carries out the responsibility, and does it well.

    ReplyDelete
  68. Webroot SecureAnywhere webroot.com/safe AntiVirus is a powerful antivirus that has been created to fight against malwares and other threats. Visit :for installing webroot.

    ReplyDelete
  69. The process of activating youtube.com/activate yourYouTube on the devices isn’t complicated at all. But since there are many different devices that you can use, the way you activate YouTube varies from device to device. download youtube.com/activate today.

    ReplyDelete
  70. Install the HP driver 123hp.com/setupto guide you through a USB or wired (Ethernet) network printer connection setup. Windows or Mac computers. Go to 123hp.com/setup and follow the instructions to install and set up the printer for your connection type.

    ReplyDelete
  71. Browse mcafee.com/activate and avail the premium features of McAfee. Get your 25-digit activation code via for McAfee mcafee.com/activate.

    ReplyDelete